Life or Livelihood…Health or Wealth

A Peek Into the COVID-19 Pandemic led Catch 22 Situation

The entire world has been reeling from the totally unprecedented Covid-19 pandemic for the past almost 17 months, which has wreaked immeasurable havoc on life and livelihood.
Covid-19, being a novel strain of virus, no vaccine or medicine was initially available to combat it. The virus was not only spreading at alarming rates, mainly through contact, but also had significant fatality rates. Therefore, the only way to prevent the wrath of the virus was to stay away from it and hence most governments across the world adopted the WHO’s recommendation of imposing ‘lockdowns’. The crucial question that emerged in this context was whether it was more important to protect life (and health) through a continued imposition of lockdowns, or livelihood (and wealth) by not bringing the economy to a halt, which was also crucial to ultimate survival! This dilemma has been one of the toughest decisions of all times for the governments, and considering the undeniable mutual interdependence of life and livelihood, has created a quintessential Catch-22 situation.
This Catch 22 situation is comparable to the famous policy dilemma of the Philips curve in economics which shows a trade-off between two major economic problems: inflation and unemployment, either of which could be reduced only at the cost of the other. In today’s pandemic, the policy dilemma is between life or livelihood, both of which are crucial to survival, and neither of which can be compromised upon at any cost!
In order to study this dilemma, it is necessary to weigh the losses caused by the pandemic to livelihood and life:

Livelihood and Wealth: The Economic Fall-Out of the Pandemic

Covid-19 and the ensuing lockdowns plunged the world into a deep economic crisis, the worst since the Great Depression of 1930’s.
At the global level, the growth rate fell to -4.5 to -6% in 2020 leading to a cumulative loss of about USD 9 trillion in 2020-21. Global trade also fell by 5.3% in 2020. In Q12020, the world’s manufacturing output growth declined by 6%. The pandemic also severely impacted the global unemployment levels with about 1.6 billion workers in the informal economy and 305 million full-time workers estimated to face job losses. About 95 million people are estimated to have entered the extreme poverty level due to the pandemic.
In India, the lockdown created a 23.9% contraction in GDP in Q12021 which is expected to recover to -7.7% in 2020-21. The manufacturing sector sharply declined by 39.3% in Q12020-21, with the IIP declining by -15.5% in 2020-21. The service sector, a major contributor to GDP, contracted by almost 16% in Q2,2020-21.
The unemployment rate rose to an unprecedented level of 23.52% in April 2020. Approximately 40 million internal migrant workers lost their jobs, causing a mass exodus back to villages in the most distressing conditions.

The Other Side of the Coin: Life and Health

Covid-19 positive cases and fatalities reached alarming levels in 2021. By July 2021 the world recorded 181mn confirmed cases, 166.15million recoveries and 3.93 million deaths. India recorded 30.23 million confirmed cases, 29.25 million recoveries and about 4 lakh deaths. Equally distressing trends are also witnessed world over. The second wave of Covid-19 in 2021 saw India and Brazil emerging as the hotspots of the virus, with India reaching its highest single-day total of more than 4 lakh cases on 6th May 2021, lockdowns, once again was the only option.

A Catch-22 situation: The Policy Dilemma

The dilemma between a lockdown for managing the virus or protecting livelihoods is unfortunately still ongoing. In spite of the strong economic fallouts of the lockdown there seems to be no other option but resorting to lockdowns to break the ‘chain of the virus’, until a significant percentage of the population is vaccinated; especially in view of the impending second and third waves of the pandemic. The policy dilemma continues inspite of representations by industries and labour groups against the lockdowns, and the advice of the medical and health organisations supporting lockdowns. Governments are committed to protect both life and livelihood, life being certainly more fundamental. Although livelihood is also of course essential for sustaining life, without life, the question of livelihood becomes meaningless. The answer to this dilemma, at least as a priority at this stage, would undoubtedly be life, reminding us of the old adage “Jaan Hai to Jahaan Hai, or “Health is Wealth “.

Sunayini Parcure Photo 2021
Prof (Dr) Sunayini Parchure

About the Author

Dr.Sunayini Parchure is a Ph.D in Economics. She was formerly the Vice Principal and Head, Department of Economics at Symbiosis College of Arts and Commerce, Pune. She has a teaching experience spanning almost a period of more than three decades at the undergraduate level coupled with about fifteen years post graduate teaching experience in economics and banking. She is also a recognised research guide for Ph.D. in the faculty of Humanities at the Symbiosis International University, SIU.
She is currently, Member, Academic Council of Symbiosis College of Arts and Commerce, Pune and visiting faculty at the PG Economics Programme and the Symbiosis Centre for Liberal Arts at Symbiosis College of Arts and Commerce, Pune.
Reading, music, travelling, writing are her other passions and she is a very social and friendly person and loves to be with people and friends.
Sunayini may be contacted at: [email protected]

Want to read more articles like this? Check out our Author Speaks page, here you will find more such content.

9 Comments

  • Priti Mastakar says:

    Completely agree with Dr Sunayini Parchure, life comes above all. Well written article bringing in quite a few contrasts, esp between the great depression and the current pandemic.

  • PUSMITA MODAK says:

    The article is beautifully written with the choice of words that is intelligible to the readers. Even though this thought of life and livelihood has been all around the globe, the perfect way of synchronising it with the trade off between the two is just marvellous.

  • Dr.Neha Agashe says:

    Thank you Ma’am for an insightful article highlighting the policy dilemma in this frightful time. The article has lucid language and hence can convey the message impact fully.

  • Dr Marcelle Samuel says:

    The current policy dilemma faced by Governments all over the world is lucidly expressed in this article by Dr Sunayini Parchure. Her comments on the contemporary macroeconomic trade-off make very interesting reading.

  • Nalini Sapkal says:

    Very well written article with the latest data.the article gives a comparative analysis of the current situation.

  • Nalini Sapkal says:

    Very well written and thought provoking article.

  • Nandini katti says:

    Excellent, well written, precise and well analyzed.

  • Rhea Patwardhan says:

    This article has managed to provide an indepth understanding on the impact of Covid19 pandemic on various matters. Ranging from the behavior of world economies to the dilemma faced by policy makers, the article has precisely covered all the major topics in a manner thats engaging and enjoyable.
    Thank you for your insight ma’am and for making it easy to comprehend. A truly interesting read and looking forward to many more!!

  • Dr. Shubhada Tamhankar says:

    Excellent article written by Dr. Sunaini Parchure. She has explained the current economic dilemma in apt words.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

loader

Director - BMH Transmotion Pvt. (I) Ltd. & DeviSthal Infrastructure Global Pvt. Ltd.
A multifaceted person – a sociologist, an entrepreneur, a management consultant, a management faculty and a very involved MOTHER.

  • To be the leading global platform for sustainable and eco-friendly gifting solutions
  • To inspire a greener, healthier, happier and more conscious world through our sustainable gifting solutions
  • To empower individuals in making environmentally responsible choices for giving gifts
  • To foster a culture of conscious consumerism through our eco-friendly gifts

By choosing Aadya Green Gifting, you become a part of our mission to create a more sustainable future. Together, we can make a positive impact on the environment. As a conscious consumer, your choices matter, and we are here to support you in your contribution towards sustainable development and green living.

    1. Sustainability (clickable, relevant picture to be provided):

    • We are committed to promoting sustainable practices and products that have a positive impact on the environment.
    • Our gifts are sourced responsibly, minimizing waste and supporting ethical suppliers.

    2. Quality (clickable relevant picture to be provided):

    • Providing high-quality, innovative, and eco-conscious products and experiences that exceed our customers' expectations are our top-most priority.

    3. Education (clickable relevant picture to be provided):

    •  We value knowledge and, in our endeavours, to empower individuals with the information and skills they need to make informed decisions about sustainability, we liaison with think tank authors across board to write for us.

    4. Customer-Centric (clickable relevant picture to be provided):

    •  Our customers are at the heart of everything we do.
    • We strive to provide exceptional service and create meaningful connections with our community.

    5. Creativity and Innovation (clickable relevant picture to be provided):

    • We celebrate creativity and innovation for designing things to deal with ‘wicked’ environmental issues.
    • We Embrace design thinking and creative problem solving as a powerful tool to develop products and services that inspire change and raise awareness about environmental issues infuses a sense of responsible ‘do ability’ to make our planet a better World.

    6. Transparency (clickable relevant picture to be provided):

    • We are open and honest in our business practices, ensuring transparency in our sourcing, manufacturing, and communication.

    7. Environmental Stewardship (clickable relevant picture to be provided):

    • We take our role as environmental stewards seriously and actively support initiatives that contribute to environmental conservation and protection.

    8. Continuous Progress (clickable relevant picture to be provided):

    • We are committed to continuous learning and improvement, regularly seeking ways to enhance our products, services, and sustainable practices.

    9. Community Impact (clickable relevant picture to be provided):

    • We strive to create a positive impact on the communities we serve, supporting local artisans and initiatives that promote sustainable development.
    • 10. Inclusivity (clickable relevant picture to be provided):
      We embrace diversity and inclusivity, welcoming individuals from all walks of life to be a part of the Green Gifting community.
    • To offer a thoughtfully curated collection of eco-friendly products for gifting
    • To offer a lifelong experiences and courses and as gifts for all reasons and seasons
    • To raise awareness on sustainable living through our innovative gifting ideas
    • To contribute to environmental conservation initiatives through our green gifting platform

    Books: They say books are windows to new worlds, and what better gift to give than the gift of knowledge? Instead of material possessions that may lose their charm, books stand the test of time, imparting wisdom, and sparking imagination with every turn of a page. By gifting our thoughtful and value creating collection of books, you open doors for your loved ones to an unexplored realm, boosting their learning agility, and promote a sustainable reading culture.
    With our 2 imprints – Alpha Zone & Books33, we cater to the specific needs of our two distinct reader segments – children and adults.
    Alpha Zone:
    Books Alpha Zone
    Alpha Zone is dedicated to our very loving and pampered alpha generation – kids born between 2010-2024 – also known as ‘glass generation’. It offers a wide range of colourful story books based on the themes of life skills, healthy habits and sustainable development. These highly engaging colourful books stand out from the pack with their eye-catching illustrations and ample ‘learn with fun’ activities. Our Alpha Zone books are written by award-winning authors of children literature and super-talented doting young moms from across India and other foreign countries.
    Books33:

    Books Books33

    offers a wide range of fictional as well as non-fictional academic books in the domains of school education - primary, secondary and senior secondary and higher education – management, engineering and humanities. Our books are written by eminent authors and academicians from across India and other foreign countries.
    Choose from a wide range of topics, from eco-conscious living and environmental conservation to sustainable business practices and personal growth. With each book, you plant the seed of knowledge, nurturing a more informed and aware individual. Giving books as a green gift comes with a multitude of benefits, both for the recipient and the environment.

    Srijanpath:

    Our Writing Workshops:

    Srijanpath 1

    Gift our Creative Writing Courses and Publishing Services to yourself or your loved ones. It is one of our most sought-after green gifts as it offers a range of benefits that not only promotes personal growth, creativity and sustainability but personal brand.

    •  Minimal Environmental Impact: Creative Writing Courses and Publishing Services are offered in both - digital online webinar based as well as on-sight workshops, which significantly reduce paper waste and other resources associated with traditional publishing methods thereby minimizing the environmental impact.
    • Fosters Creativity and Expression: These gifts provide an opportunity to your loved ones to explore their creative potential and express themselves through writing. Encouraging creativity is not only personally fulfilling but also contributes to a more imaginative and innovative society.
    • Lifelong Learning: Gifting Writing Courses promotes a culture of continuous learning and intellectual curiosity. Participants can continue to engage with the materials and apply what they've learned long after the course has ended.
    • Sustainable Publishing: For aspiring authors, our publishing Services provide a more sustainable approach to sharing their work with the world. Our hybrid publishing formats reduce the need for physical copies, which can lead to excess paper and emissions associated with distribution.
    • Encourages Storytelling for Change: Creative writing can be a powerful tool for addressing social and environmental issues. By encouraging storytelling for change, these gifts inspire authors to use their craft to raise awareness about sustainability, climate change, and other important topics.
    • Supports Aspiring Authors: Gifting Publishing Services can be a significant boost for aspiring authors who may not have access to traditional publishing avenues. By providing the opportunity for their work to reach a wider audience, you support and encourage their creative endeavors.
    • Meaningful and Thoughtful Gift: Offering Creative Writing Courses and Publishing Services as gifts demonstrates your thoughtfulness and consideration for your loved ones’ interests and passions. It shows that you value their creativity and growth as an individual.
      By choosing to gift Creative Writing Courses and Publishing Services, you contribute to a more sustainable, creative, and environmentally conscious gift-giving culture. These gifts empower individuals to express themselves, promote lifelong learning, and encourage positive change through the power of storytelling.

    In a world bustling with distractions, there is something truly magical about disconnecting from the chaos and immersing oneself in the serenity of nature to explore the depths of creative expression. Aadya Green Gifting is glad to introduce the ultimate green gift – Residential Writing Retreats – a once in a lifetime kind of opportunity to embark on a transformative journey of self-discovery, inspiration, and co-consciousness. There cannot be any gift more precious than this to gift to yourself and your loved ones.

    •  Embrace the Power of Words: Amidst Nature's Embrace, at the heart of our Residential Writing Retreats is the profound connection between creativity and nature. Surrounded by lush landscapes and untouched beauty, participants find solace and inspiration in the great outdoors. The setting becomes the canvas for untold stories, unexplored emotions, and boundless imagination.
    • A Sustainable Sanctuary for Artistic Souls: Our Residential Writing Retreats are meticulously crafted to align with our commitment to sustainability. We choose eco-friendly venues that leave a minimal ecological footprint, providing an immersive experience that respects and protects the environment. From sustainable practices to locally sourced cuisine, every aspect of our retreats reflects our dedication to preserving the beauty of our planet.
    • Connection to Nature: Many creative writing courses incorporate nature and the environment as themes or sources of inspiration. This connection to nature can lead to a deeper appreciation for the natural world and a desire to protect it.
    • Nurturing Creativity: One word at a time led by experienced facilitators, our Residential Writing Retreats offer a nurturing environment where creativity flourishes. Through guided writing sessions, mindfulness exercises, and creative workshops, participants embark on a profound inward journey, discovering the power of their words in the midst of nature's embrace.
    • A Gift Beyond Material Possessions: In a world dominated by material possessions, our Residential Writing Retreats stand apart as a truly thoughtful and meaningful gift. It transcends the boundaries of the material realm, leaving an indelible impression on the heart and soul of the recipient. It is an experience cherished forever - a gift that keeps on giving.

    Fill The Form ToGet Discounts-N-Updates to WIN Gift Bonanza

      Stories are the best way to come closer to children and Dr Monica Khanna is doing fabulous work in that sense. It’s always mesmerizing to read the stories she creates. Not only the kids, but even parents enjoy every bit of them.

      Little Chimpu’s adventure through the jungle wherein she discovers the truth about ferocious Sher Dadu, is a beautiful story about finding friends in the most unlikely of people.

      This picture book is such a delight to read. The book is beautifully illustrated with a good story line and strong vocabulary. I liked in this book is using the relations like ‘chachu’, ‘mamu’ and others which the kids are missing due to nuclear family... I must say the author has touched the chord of the heart with the sweet language used in the book..It’s a must read book for all the young kids.

      A Wormy Tale is a delightful picture story book that offers the curious mind of a child the perfect blend of fun and relatable characters, vibrant illustrations and significant learnings that seep in with simplicity and are finally sealed with the array of activities it offers. This is a book with a wholesome experience, so read on!

      This lovely book teaches you to think smart and not get carried away by appearances. Best wishes to Dr Monica Khanna for her amazing creation.

      Dr. Monica Khanna has come out with one more offering for you all. Such a wonderful and endearing story! It takes us to that time of our lives when we believed that everything around us is black or white. Childhood is so much fun and so full of innocence. The characters in this story are so believable, with human-like qualities. Kind, gentle, witty, intelligent, sharp, sly and so on... Each young reader will enjoy reading this story because it is so relatable. You can find people with such qualities all around you.

      The well-crafted, colourful illustrations of the enthusiastic musicians among insects – grasshoppers, katydids and hawkmoths, the frogs with their crafty expressions and the thoughtful busy bee, make it a lively read. Woven into the story are the fun facts of each insect, making it educative and inspiring too, thus inculcating the love of nature to early readers.

      Katie Bagli’s new book promises to bring back the concert we have missed ever since the pandemic hit us. She beautifully weaves science and fiction, urging her young readers to learn about the techniques used by the wetland musicians - the grasshoppers, the katydids and the hawkmoths. Then there are the subtle values and undertones that make for great learning for children the vacation in nature, the loving aunt, the dutiful bee, or even the love for the garden insects.

      Katie Bagli’s stories are filled with wild imagination yet grounded in facts.She brings to life the mundane and often overlooked facts with wit and humour, in her stories, as also in ‘The Insect Concert’. Her characters are driven by a moral so subtle that children may hardly realize the important life values they are imbibing just by reading her books. Her stories are lessons in science and art as each panel bursts into vivacious colours and tickles the imagination of the young reader. Truly delightful and a must read for all.

      This book ‘Insect Concert’ by Katie Bagli is another gem from her treasure trove of stories about nature. Through a simple yet novel story, she manages to develop an interest in the animal kingdom and also provide a new learning. There are some activities too which children will enjoy. The illustrations add to the storyline and make the book more interesting for the young reader. I wish Katie more power to her pen.

      Sunny Side Up’ is a book of joy for every child. With colourful illustrations and child friendly language this book opens up a world of different kinds of food to the young minds.

      An instant hit - With colorful illustrations and an engaging narrative, this playful nature book is perfect for curious toddlers. A Wormy Tale..an engaging, simple yet extraordinary new story from Katie Bagli, number one bestseller and fastest growing children’s author in the country

      Through this story, A Wormy Tale, the author Katie Bagli highlights earthworms as a part of the ecosystem. Educators can use this story for crossdisciplinary and interdisciplinary thinking within the national curriculum. Katie’s love for nature is evident in all her books.

      To be hired in today’s global marketplace, employers demand more than basic ‘hard’ skills. The difference between a frustrated candidate and a sought-after recruit, the long-term worker and a compelling leader, or the stagnant professional and the rising manager can be the ‘soft’ skills each exercises in the workplace. This highly researched book analyses the job environment of today and for the future where ‘soft’ skills become a more critical attribute. The reader gleans valuable guidance on how to acquire and improve these ‘soft’ skills for a more enriching career.

      Alpha Zone book – ‘Sunny Side Up’ - shows the variety of food that is present round the world. All of us know the common pizza or burger but there are many delicious dishes out there that many have not experienced. This book encourages us to be curious and to learn, enjoy and experience the art of the culinary skill.

      I’ve absolutely no hesitation in saying that even after working for 30+ years in Manufacturing and Education sectors, I was not able to correlate nonverbal communication skills of a person with his personality and credibility. But after getting in touch with Prof (Dr) Shalini Verma and going through her first book, ‘BODY LANGUAGE: YOUR SUCCESS MANTRA, (2005)’ I immediately fell in love with this beautiful subject and understood that body language is an important personality trait of any person. I am delighted to know that Dr Verma is bringing out a multi-title series of that inspiring book after 15 years, which is surely going to be another ‘hit’ and beneficial for the readers, especially the Gen Z youth, who gravely need the maturity to understand and cope with complex personal & professional relationships to move forward in life.

      Children’s literature largely trivialises and glosses over such issues such as gender or colour biases. But this book deals with the sensitive issue of our proclivity or preference for fair skin colour. In the context of the Indian subcontinent, such debates and discussions should be encouraged so that children grow up with a healthy self-image and grow up with the right attitudes that skin colour is secondary to inner beauty. Dr Monica’s sensitive handling of this subject deserves to be applauded. Kudos!

      This book talks about the fact that beauty has no standards - it’s the way one looks at one own self. I am sure this book will surely attract young readers. I wish all the best for the book.

      Kudos to Books33 for coming up with a separate segment of Children Books under its imprint Alpha Zone. Your initiative will definitely make parents and teachers understand the importance of inculcating reading habits in your kids right from their young age. I appreciate Dr Monica Khanna for her bookSunny Side Up’ and love its ‘kahani mein twist’ which made it all the more exciting.

      A lovely rhyming style and delightful words make this book effortlessly readable. Dr Khanna addresses a vital issue of our times in this allegorical tale of female crow.

      One may speak good English, bad English, good Hindi, bad Hindi, a mix of Hindi-English or 'Hinglish', Spanglish, Pig-Latin, Gibberish, Mumbling or Double-speak, the sub-text that one's body speaks is just ONE -- CREDIBLE or NOT CREDIBLE! Be aware of your body language. You can lie in your words, but the body never lies. We communicate through our Body all the time, even when we don't realize it. However, there are very few expertswho can deeply understand, analyse and decode Body Language. Dr Shalini Verma is one of them.

      Kyra’s Return Flight conveys through a delightful story the very important message that there is great joy and power in accepting ourselves as we are,and not falling prey to harmful social prejudices about what is attractive or good. I greatly recommend this wonderful book about loving oneself!

      ‘Sunny Side Up’ authored by Dr Monica Khanna is a slice of delight with just the right bite.

      ‘Sunny Side Up’ is a delightfully wicked book! A complete treat for kids of all shapes, sizes and taste; those who fuss around their meals and those who devour their food. A visual treat for the eyes that moistened my curiosity palate, as I turned each page to follow Sunny’s exciting culinary adventures. An astonishing finale, that enhanced some beautiful childhood memories.

      Katie Bagli has two interests, nature and children. She has two talents, writing and drawing. As a story teller, she engages children with her colourful puppets and other visual aids, bringing to life the characters in her books.

      Dr Monica Khanna’s new book ‘Kyra’s Return Flight’ dwells deeper into the age-old societal challenges of colour differentiation amongst humans. Through a simple life story of a crow, she brings to the front the problem that we have of self-pity and self-doubt that dark coloured people face through the generations. As a school principal, I definitely recommend Monica’s books in all school libraries and encourage parents to share a copy with their kids.

      My compliments to the author for developing rich and novel content in an area that still lies underexplored. With so little information available on body language in the Indian context, I can imagine how much hard work
      would have gone into creating a book like this. This book is beautifully crafted in terms of quality content and relevance in the current context.

      Former General Manager from State Bank of India

      An Electrical Engineer and a first-generation entrepreneur with PhD in Management

      Has been working in the corporate world for the last 10 years

      A 17-year-old bright student of 11th standard at Dibrugarh, Assam

      A student of IBDP program (at DYPIS) in Mumbai, India

      Analyst at Deloitte USI

      A 15-year-old student of class 10 at Apeejay School - Panchsheel Park, New Delhi

      A 15-year-old student of class 10 at St. Mary’s ICSE School, Navi Mumbai.

      An M.A. in English Literature from Tezpur University, Assam

      A NIFT graduate and a professional Jewellery Designer

      An educator by the day and a poet by night

      A professional Microbiologist and an avid nature lover

      Currently pursuing BDS & aspires to become a successful writer

      A Communication Professor & Authorpreneur

      English Language and Personality Development skills Trainer

      Aspires to make career and writing and become a successful writer

      Winner of ‘Mrs Karnataka’ and ‘Inner Beauty’ titles

      A 13-year old 8th grader studying in Mangaluru, Karnataka

      Student of English Honours at Calcutta University, West Bengal

      A student of airport handling at YMCA, Delhi.

      An engineer by profession and a writer by passion

      Author & co-author of multiple books and anthologies

      A nine-year-old student of Silver Oaks International School, Hyderabad

      A Grade-III student of Silver Oaks International School, Hyderabad

      She adorns the hat of a multitasker - an educationist, an artist, a poet, a photographer, an author, a homemaker, a wife and above all a MOTHER

      3rd grader studying in Silver Oaks International School, Hyderabad

      A writer by passion and a Physicist by profession

      Sr. ERO (Sr. Employee Relations Officer) at Indian Oil Corporation Limited

      Associate Professor at Indira Institute of Business Management

      Registering with Books33 is the 1st step to joining our community and earning a ‘Bookoholics badge’ – an ENTRY TICKET to avail plethora of opportunities and discount coupons. And the good news is that registering with us is absolutely FREE!

      BOOKS33 is a HOME of the AUTHORS, By the AUTHORS & For the AUTHORS. We give 360 degree publishing assistance. We not only PUBLISH your books but also PROMOTE & MARKET those books across the world and help you in spreading your wings across the book readers' community. We provide end-to-end assistance in publishing, promotion, and positioning of your books under just ONE roof.